Purple & Pink - Gram's diagnostic link

My day started off with a microbiology class. As usual, yes, I was sleep deprived, and no, I didn't doze off in class. I wouldn't dare to do that, considering the fact that even if I miss a single sentence uttered by my Professor, I'd never be able to catch up.

And that I was way too much of a 'nerd', as my friends called me, to even think about sleeping in a class.

So the class was going on, and I was furiously writing down everything on the board, completely zoning out on what my Professor was explaining, when I heard him emphasise a particular point which I found was very interesting.

That gram staining was completely irrelevant in determining the phylogeny or classification of a bacteria. 

But whenever I'd read about gram staining in high school, the books had always said that it was a means of classification of bacteria. Gram staining, in my mind, as in many of my peers, was synonymous to that of bacterial classification. But if this technique wasn't used for classification, what was it used for? And that got me to thinking - what was the original thought process or purpose for which gram staining was first created as a technique? 

So in the evening, taking a break from the whirlwind of assignments, test prep and research work, I sat, trying to learn a bit more about gram staining.

But before I could actually do some serious reading, I was drawn to the history of how this staining techniue was developed. It was discovered by Hans Christian Gram, the youngest of the seven children of a law professor who tried very hard to shift his son's attention away from the sciences. But Gram was determined - he got his degree and later joined Karl Friedländer's lab, where they were studying the bacterial etiology of pneumonia. They had found two bacterial samples from the lung tissues retrieved from patients suffering from pneumonia - a bacillus and a coccus.  Friedländer declared that the bacillus the causative agent, but his rival, Albert Fraenkel promptly proclaimed that it was coccus which caused the disease. 

The question arose - how would this debate be solved? No staining technique existed to visualize bacteria in lung tissue, as the organisms were lost against the background of inflamed tissue. Since neither of the bacteria could be recovered, both the scientists continued insulting each other, that the other's result was due to a contamination or experimental mishandling. 

And this is where Gram came into the picture, creating a technique still being taught to students, almost by accident. While working late, Gram spilled potassium iodide over sections of lung tissue that had been stained with methyl violet. After attempting to remove the stain with alcohol, Gram noted that in all lung sections the cocci retained the methyl violet, but the bacilli were decolorized. Gram became the first to visualize bacteria in lung tissue, and to his surprise, he found both organisms. 

But these results were against his mentor's claims - however, Friedländer later conceded that it was probably that the pneumonia could be caused by both the coccus and the bacillus. 

Take note - this technique began off for diagnostic purposes, not for classification.

To those of you who don't know what gram staining is, here is your answer. In simple terms, it can be described as the capability of a bacteria's cell wall to take in a stain, giving rise to a colour. And based on this colour, they are classified as gram positive or gram negative.

The procedure for gram staining is quite simple - a bacterial culture is grown overnight and subcultured till the cells are in an early log stage (i.e, healthy and growing). A bit of the culture is taken in a glass slide, smeared and let to air dry after which it is heat-fixed. This is followed by a series of staining (usually staining by crystal violet and counter-staining by safranin) and washing after which the cells are observed under a microscope. Gram positive bacteria appear purple and gram negative bacteria appear pink. 


And what's the basis of this color? 

One of the main features of a bacterial cell wall is the presence of peptidoglycan (a polymer of sugars and amino acids) and gram staining takes advantage of this particular characteristic. Not all bacterial strains have the same level/thickness of peptidoglycan in their cell wall. Gram positive bacteria have a thick peptidoglycan layer that retains the crystal violet stain, making it appear purple under the microscope. Gram negative bacteria, however, have a thin peptidoglycan layer and an outer membrane, meaning, that the stain can be easily washed away after staining. This means that when they are staining by the counter stain, they show its colour (in the case of safranin, a pink or red colour). 

It's been established that it's the thickness of the peptidoglycan that gives the differential staining - so at what thickness of peptidoglycan is a bacteria gram positive or gram negative? 

As of 2016, it has been theorized that Gram positive bacteria possess a thick (20–80 nm) peptidoglycan layer, while Gram negative bacteria have a relatively thin (<10 nm) peptidoglycan layer (Mai-Prochnow et al., 2016). But Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens, a member of phylum Bacillota, has a peptidoglycan layer of thickness 12-18nm and stains gram positive, a clear exception to this rule. 

Apart from this, some bacteria are gram variable, i.e, stains both gram positive and negative and cannot be reliably classified as gram positive or negative. This can be due to external environmental factors or due to variability in cell wall composition. Due to this, a single bacteria can show gram positive and negative staining in its life time. 

Sometimes, just like the false positives we get in diagnostic tests, the same can happen with bacteria too! Gram positive bacteria such Mycobacterium have very sensitive cells which may break during the cell giving gram stain negative, showing that this mechanism of classification is variable and not too dependable.

Those who think gram staining is used for classification are very much mistaken - this technique gives no information on the metabolism of the organism, of the nutrients it requires to grow, and it most definitely cannot be used to map the phylogeny of the organism. 

Right now, gram staining is being used mainly to help doctors diagnose bacterial infections and choose the most effective antibiotic treatment. But apart from that - is it being used anywhere else? I doubt it. 

I still remember learning about bacteria in high school and reading a paragraph that they were of two types - those which stained gram positive and those which stained gram negative. 

Do I miss the days when that's all bacteria meant to me? When I didn't have to try cope and keep up with the never-ending stream of names of bacterial phyla and classes? 

Now that I know there's so much more than just gram staining that define the beauty of bacteria, do I ever wish I could revert to that stage of ignorance? Or have I resigned to my fate and decided to do the best I can with the information being uploaded into my brain?

Well, I guess that's a question best left unanwered.

I hope you learnt a bit more about gram staining and found it just as interesting as I did!

Do let me know your thoughts below:))


Cheers,

Vibha


Comments

Popular Posts